2slicesbreadany kind - avoid bread that is too crusty or bread with holes
2slicesAmerican cheeseor your favorite cheese
Buttersoftened
Instructions
Preheat air fryer to 400°F.
Place 2 slices American cheese between 2 slices bread.
Butter the outside of both the top bread slice and the bottom bread slice.
Using tongs or a spatula, place sandwich in air fryer basket and cook for 5 minutes turning halfway through cooking. Air fry until golden brown and melty to your liking. Note: for an air fryer toaster oven model with a tray, cook for 7-9 minutes instead.
Remove from the air fryer and enjoy!
Tried this recipe?Let us know in the comments below!
Notes
Use your favorite cheese or combination of cheeses.
Use your favorite bread. Choose bread that doesn't have holes in it or bread that is too crusty.
Cook time may vary depending on your specific air fryer model. All air fryers vary.
If cooking in multiple batches, check on the remaining batches early, as they may cook more quickly.
A thin layer of butter that covers the entire outside of each slice of bread is important when buttering the bread to ensure the bread toasts evenly.
Buttering the insides of each slice of bread is optional, but very tasty.